The story is true (some details omitted for privacy); the names are fake.
Content Warning: Suicide
***
A few days later, I came over with shepherd’s pie, only now it was just for “Ezra”. Unfortunately, I didn’t manage to bring it over until 8:30 PM and it turned out it was the first meal Ezra had eaten all day. I felt bad about that.
I gave him back the copy of your house key you had given me. Ezra offered me some of your things. Books. Bags. Hats. Clothes. Even lightly used wedding presents from your wedding to him. (I protested; he said he didn’t want them.)
I realized I still had the black party dress you had loaned me years ago, saying you wanted me to give it back to you after you lost weight. Your weight tended to fluctuate a lot because of all the medications you were taking. I had forgotten to give the dress back. I guessed it was mine now.

It was weird taking your things. It felt uncomfortable to want and to take your things, and it felt uncomfortable to not want your things and to leave them behind. The whole time I was in your house, it was a struggle not to cry. Conversation with Ezra was awkward and awful. I felt terrible for Ezra, but I couldn’t wait to leave, and I felt horrible about that.
***
Later, we found out your family didn’t want people taking your things yet; they wanted to go through your belongings first. I didn’t offer anything back though. I didn’t have the will to return your belongings after the whole experience of taking them in the first place.
Besides, I rationalized, I hadn’t taken anything of real or sentimental value, like jewelry or photos or anything like that. Really just a book no one else would be interested in, and clothes in styles and sizes unlikely to fit your other female friends/relatives. Also, random shit – a package of cookies you liked that Ezra didn’t care for, an open box of pantyliners to spare Ezra the embarrassment of having to ask another woman. That sort of thing.
***
It’s interesting to see how different mutual friends cope with grief in different ways. After your suicide, “Miriam” posted a PSA* on Facebook about depression, mental health, suicide awareness, alluding to your decades long struggle with clinical depression. “Eliora” found solace in Torah learning – organizing Torah learning in your memory. I didn’t really find solace in either, to be honest, but it was a nice thought.
***
I tried to look out for Ezra. He was having some health problems himself and at one point, he was sending updates on his own health to all your friends through your email address. It killed me every time I got an email from “you” knowing that you were dead, but I couldn’t really ask him to do otherwise.

I picked up groceries for him a couple times, but after a while, I stopped remembering to reach out. I still feel bad about that.
***
Your death was still pretty fresh at Yom Kippur that year. Husband (who dislikes everything about Yom Kippur, is particularly bad at fasting all day, and who usually spends Yom Kippur sleeping or reading at home) showed up for the afternoon services, making the gap in the schedule that I used to spend at your house feel less empty. It was quite sweet of him, actually.
After Yom Kippur ended, I was standing in line for the communal pot luck break fast buffet with another congregant.
Congregant: You heard about Joyce? So sad…
JYP: *nods in agreement/sympathy*
Congregant: Did you know her?
JYP: I’m wearing her dress right now.
It was that black party dress with a white sweater over it. White sweater because it’s traditional to wear white on Yom Kippur and also because the top of the dress didn’t really fit me at all (you were considerably more well-endowed). I should probably get it tailored.

The congregant looked surprised. I guess no one expects people with a 20+ year age gap to be friends.
***
*I’ll do a Miriam-style PSA here and mention that September is Suicide Prevention Awareness Month.
***
[…] Part 2, Part 3, Part 4 […]
LikeLike
[…] Part 3, Part 4 […]
LikeLike
[…] Part 4 […]
LikeLike
Fascinating story, while also very sad…
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is sad.
So this was going to be 6 parts, with part 6 finally not being so sad and having more closure. I’m struggling with Part 5. It’s more sadness and regret, and some extremely uncomfortable things for me to write. Part of me is tempted to not bother publishing what would be Part 5 since it’s more sadness and to skip to “Part 6/The end”. Haven’t decided.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it would feel strange to take things that belonged to a dead friend and it would feel especially creepy to get email from her account.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Taking her belonging wasn’t so weird or creepy. This might be a men vs. women thing, I feel like women share clothes with each other all the time. It was slightly odd the first time I wore her sweatshirt, but not uncomfortable, and I’ve worn it multiple times since.
But the emails drove me crazy!
LikeLiked by 1 person
True. We men don’t borrow clothes. Men like me are simpletons compared to women when it comes to fashion. If it’s black, I’ll wear it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Even though it took you two years, the emotions you express feel very immediate. I can feel the discomfort of trying to work through the shock and grief and the oddities accompanying death.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! Part of the reason this is so long (it was to be 6 parts, but I’m debating about cutting one of them) is that I really didn’t want this to be a distanced summation. I really wanted to capture the feelings at each stage, from getting the news at the wedding, to taking her stuff, to the sense of closure in Part 6 (Which may become Part 5 if I cut out existing Part 5, which has excessive sadness and regret – still debating), vs. just a “this happened, it was really sad, get help if you feel suicidal” summary.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think you should include part 5. You’ve come this far, might as well be thorough about it. Stay real.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So raw. I can only guess how hard it must have been, talking to Ezra so soon after losing her. And taking/not taking her things. And the emails from her address. 😢😢😢Are you in touch with Ezra? I hope he’s okay. A sort of neighbour lost her husband recently. I barely know her but it took all my courage to take her some flowers, a card and a carton of home laid eggs. I think it’s sooo much harder when you are so deeply emotionally affected yourself.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I feel embarrassed and ashamed to admit that I’ve fallen out of contact with Ezra and I feel really bad about it. Like I picked up groceries for him a few times, including once or twice during the pandemic, but I just stopped thinking to reach out. One of the congregations we were part of gave him a group holiday gift that year, which I also contributed to. I could reach out. It feels awkward, but I could. I probably should.
It is hard to reach out to someone who is grieving if you don’t know them well. What you did for your neighbor is really sweet and thoughtful.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well it sounds like you haven’t totally lost contact, if you bought groceries during the pandemic. You’re grieving too. It’s definitely not an easy position, especially in if you don’t know him well. I made myself do that for the neighbour. The Mum’s at the kids’ new school have been amazing since they heard I have cancer. They cook for me, send me sweet messages, send me organic herbal tea… and they hardly know me. It felt like a kindness I should learn to imitate. I have always been so conscious of people’s privacy and also of my own awkwardness and fear. So I made the card and then took the dog straight over (the dog is how I met this neighbour) before I could talk myself out of it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I mean, I went grocery shopping for him early in the pandemic – think April 2020, not you know, the continued pandemic of 2021. Truthfully, I don’t even know if he is still living in the area. I guess there is only one way to find out, which is by reaching out.
That is really sweet about the kindness you’ve received from the other moms. How are you feeling?
The dog is such a great companion for moments like this. If the neighbor is appreciative, you take credit for the idea, and if it’s awkward or uncomfortable, you can say it was your dog’s idea! 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
🤣🤣. She was appreciative. She has been kind too like the Mums. I feel I should reach out again. It must be so lonely to lose a partner of fifty years. We’re in Lockdown at the moment and, due to chemo, I don’t do any shopping. So gifts must be from the home. We had an egg shortage. 🤣🤣. Best excuse ever. I had my last chemo today. Quite a milestone. Very much an anti climax. Radiation next. Such a strange lumpy journey.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Especially kind of you to give your neighbor eggs when it’s harder for you to go out and get more provisions.
I was talking to a work colleague in Victoria and the lockdown situation sounded quite difficult. She said they’re on 250 non-consecutive days of lockdown and that there are riots/protests all the time. A rough situation.
Congrats on your last chemo! Wishing you good health and strength!
LikeLiked by 1 person
So painful to read! Must have felt.. different to wear HER clothes. Age is immaterial in friendship and you had a good one. This breaks my heart
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was odd at first, but the clothes thing became normalized. I’ve now worn her sweatshirt multiple times and it feels both like her belonging and my belonging. Despite the age gap, she had a bunch of clothing in styles that I, a much younger person, would wear.
Thank you – we had a sizeable age gap, and there are elements of friendship that didn’t really happen because of it (eg. friendship activities outside of her house). But we were truly friends.
LikeLike
Oh, I have friends 80 and older 😉
I get it about the clothes.. Even if it took a while. When I wear my mom’s clothes, I feel like her 🙂 So it is easy to imagine why it could have been initially unsettling.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You rock! Really impressive that you’ve been able to make friends who are so much older than you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You too, regarding having friends much older. Although I’m very sorry about this friend 😔
LikeLike
I really appreciate how real you are.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’ll admit I’m now struggling with whether to post Part 5 (more sadness, regret, and arguably too much realness) or skip to Part 6 which is the end, is not so sad, and that has more of a closure ending. Or if I can edit some of the excessive sadness/realness out of Part 5. Decisions…
LikeLiked by 1 person
your realness is one of your strengths, I think.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Real life is rarely neat and easy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That is certainly true.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very sad and beautiful. Life doesn’t stop for others.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very true
LikeLiked by 1 person
Getting email Ezra from her email address must have been so strange.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hated it. I get why he did it; it was easier for him to just log in to Joyce’s account and send a mass update email to her contacts rather than having to import them into his. But I hated this so much. I didn’t feel like I could tell him though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, not exactly the kind of thing you could say without upsetting him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My heart goes out to you on this powerful journey through the raw emotions of grief and loss. I have experienced a great deal of grief and loss in my life. Wearing Joyce’s clothes honored your connection. My Orthodox friends were told they were not allowed to sit Shiva for their son after he committed suicide. They did it anyway and those of us that loved him and them more than the “Law” showed up. 💔
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for sharing. I am so sorry to hear about your friends’ experience after their son’s suicide. That is such an insensitive response from the Rabbi. My own friend Joyce was not Orthodox, her family was, but they didn’t appear to have any halachic issues with sitting Shiva for her. I am glad in your friends’ case that they did what they needed to do.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was a horrible and heartbreaking response, but thankfully they did what felt right for them. I was so relieved to see that a houseful of people showed up from all Jewish walks of life and that his very frum family extended themselves warmly to his near and dear friends from the Keshet community.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That is nice that the different communities of his life were able to come together to mourn and celebrate his life. I suppose that in the face of death and tragedy, we realize how petty these distinctions are. It would be good if we could come together before tragedy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
[…] Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4 […]
LikeLike
[…] 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part […]
LikeLike
[…] Muse. For the full story, read the six-part series I wrote last year: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, Part […]
LikeLike
[…] course, the house wasn’t really Joyce’s and it hadn’t been for a long time. I gave the house key that Joyce had given me back to “Ezra” days after her suicide because I was no longer comfortable keeping it; it was no longer appropriate. Also, the exterior of […]
LikeLike
[…] six–part series I wrote about my friend who committed suicide. Writing it was deeply meaningful and important to me. Almost […]
LikeLike